ISLAMABAD
Former High Court judge Syed Manzoor Gilani has called for urgent constitutional and legal reforms to address longstanding ambiguities in the relationship between Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJK) and Pakistan, warning that unresolved questions about the legal status of AJK state subjects could undermine their access to employment opportunities and deepen public grievances.
Commenting on the reported Islamabad High Court order concerning the eligibility of AJK state subjects for government employment in Islamabad, Gilani said the development had brought a long-standing legal and constitutional dilemma into sharp focus.
He maintained that the position reflected in the order could be consistent with the existing constitutional and legal framework, despite administrative practices that had historically followed a different course. He argued that the contradiction between established practice and the legal position underscored the need for a clear, consistent and legally sustainable arrangement governing the status and rights of AJK residents in Pakistan.
Gilani said the unresolved Jammu and Kashmir dispute must not become a reason for leaving the people of Azad Jammu and Kashmir in prolonged legal uncertainty or restricting their legitimate opportunities. He emphasised that the issue required a serious policy response rather than continued reliance on administrative practices that might not withstand legal scrutiny.
“I have been raising this issue for the past 30 years: the people of Azad Jammu and Kashmir must not be made hostages to the unresolved Kashmir dispute at the cost of their legal status, rights and opportunities,” he said.
The former judge attributed the persistence of the problem to the failure of successive political leaderships in AJK to establish a clear legal framework for the region’s relationship with Pakistan. He stressed that the matter could only be addressed sustainably through appropriate constitutional and legislative measures, supported by effective institutional coordination.
He called on the newly formed AJK government, comprising a younger generation of political leaders, to recognise the practical implications of the existing legal uncertainty and make the issue a priority. The government, he said, should initiate a serious process to clarify the legal position of AJK state subjects and protect their legitimate interests through constitutionally sound arrangements.
Gilani also cautioned that prolonged uncertainty over employment eligibility and other rights could intensify public frustration and provide opportunities for separatist narratives to gain ground. He urged the political leadership to address these concerns proactively, stressing that legal clarity and equal treatment under applicable laws were essential to maintaining public confidence and strengthening ties between AJK and Pakistan.
He further emphasised that the region’s distinct constitutional position and the unresolved Kashmir dispute must be taken into account while formulating any legal solution. However, these considerations, he argued, should not indefinitely prevent the development of clear arrangements to govern the rights and practical needs of AJK residents living in Pakistan.
Gilani called for a constructive, legally grounded approach that reconciles the constitutional status of Azad Jammu and Kashmir with the legitimate interests of its people. He maintained that resolving these questions would help eliminate avoidable legal disputes, improve institutional coordination and establish a more predictable framework for relations between AJK and Pakistan.
He concluded that the time had come for AJK’s political leadership to move beyond decades of ambiguity and pursue durable constitutional and legal solutions that safeguard the rights of state subjects, strengthen public confidence and prevent unresolved administrative and legal issues from becoming a source of further alienation.